J. Cochrane je profesor na Stanfordu. Upravo je objavio znanstveni članak u renomiranom časopisu, a na svom blogu opisao je povijest nastanka i objave tog rada:
“I wrote the paper in the spring and summer of 2013, posted it to the internet, and started giving talks. Here’s the story of its publication:
- September 2013. Submitted to AER; NBER and SSRN working papers issued.
- June 2014. Rejected from AER. 3 good referee reports and thoughtful editor report.
- October 2014. Submit revision to QJE.
- December 2014. Rejected from QJE. 3 more thoughtful referee reports and editor report.
- January 2015. Submit revision to JME.
- April 2016. Revise and resubmit from JME. 3 detailed referee reports and long and thoughtful editor report.
- June 2016. Send revision to JME
- July 2017. Accept with minor revisions from JME. Many (good) comments from editor
- August 2017. Final revision to JME
- September 2017. Proofs, publication online.
- December 2017. Published.“
Neki zaključci:
Akademsko publiciranje nije koristan način komunikacije između istraživača i drugih interesenata.
Časopisi su postali arhiva, knjižnica, skladište konačnih radova za buduće generacije.
Članci u časopisima su alat za profesionalno napredovanje.
Časopisi češće odbijaju radove, a oni koji se objavljuju imaju manje revizija.
Urednici su postali odlučniji.
http://johnhcochrane.blogspot.hr/2017/09/a-paper-and-publishing.html